More than three decades after one of the most astonishing upsets in darts history, Larry 'The Bald Eagle' Butler remains the only American to have won a PDC major on European soil. His 1994 World Matchplay triumph, achieved against the odds, is a record that still stands 32 years later.
Born on July 21, 1957, Butler built his reputation in North America, winning the New York Open in 1993, 1994 and 1995, the Darts America Championship in 1994, and the World Bullshooter Championship in 1991, 1992 and 1993. He also enjoyed considerable success at the Cincinnati Spring Fling Open, winning in 1991, 1992, 1994 and 1995. However, breaking through internationally was difficult for American players, with major tournaments primarily staged in Europe, and the distance, travel costs and limited opportunities presenting significant obstacles.
Butler made his BDO World Championship debut in 1992, losing in the first round to Dennis Priestley. The darts split in 1993 opened new doors, and Butler was among the North American players invited to compete in the newly formed WDC's events. In the inaugural WDC World Championship in 1994, he failed to progress beyond the group stage but defeated three-time world champion John Lowe.
That victory was an early indication of what was to come. At the 1994 World Matchplay in Blackpool, Butler entered without being considered a major favourite. He defeated Steve Raw in the first round, Jerry Umberger next, and Scottish legend Jocky Wilson in the quarter-finals. Shayne Burgess awaited in the semi-finals, and Butler won that too to reach the final. There he faced Dennis Priestley, the man who had beaten him at the 1992 BDO World Championship. Butler produced a 16-12 victory to claim the trophy and the £10,000 first prize. The significance was enormous: he became the first American to win a PDC major on European soil, and to this day remains the only player from the United States to have achieved that feat.
Following his historic triumph, Butler competed at the PDC World Championship in 1995, 1996 and 1997. Although he never reached another final, he recorded victories over former world champions Keith Deller and John Lowe, and also defeated former world number one Rod Harrington. His best run came in 1996, when he reached the quarter-finals before losing to Jamie Harvey. After the 1997 World Championship, he largely disappeared from the regular international circuit, remaining active in North America.
In 2007, Butler began competing in international events more frequently again. He won the USA Dart Classic, a WDF tournament, and in 2008 qualified for the Las Vegas Desert Classic as one of four North American qualifiers, marking his first appearance at a major televised tournament in more than ten years. His comeback ended in the first round with a 6-4 loss to England's Alan Tabern. In April 2009, he entered sixteen Players Championships and UK Open qualifiers, reaching the prize-money stages in thirteen, with his best result a quarter-final appearance at a regional event in the West Midlands on April 1. Later that year, he produced a nine-darter at a Players Championship in Las Vegas, though he lost 6-2 to Jan van der Rassel in the second round.
Butler continued to accumulate titles in North America. In 2009, he partnered Canadian champion Bob Sinnaeve, winning the cricket doubles at the North American Open in Boston and the Windy City Open in Chicago, and the 501 doubles at the Buckeye Open in Columbus, Ohio. In 2010, he won both the 501 singles and cricket singles at the USA Darts Classic in Connecticut, competing in a field of more than 200 players. His 501 singles victory earned him an invitation to the World Masters and a place in the United States team for the 2011 WDF World Cup in Ireland. In 2011, he won the National Cricket Championship and the 501 singles in Las Vegas.
In 2013, Butler partnered Darin Young at the PDC World Cup of Darts. The American duo lost 5-4 to Finland and 5-3 to Germany, finishing bottom of Group F. A year later, they reached the second round, where they faced England. Butler took on Phil Taylor in the singles, with Taylor winning, but Darin Young produced a surprise by defeating Adrian Lewis. England proved too strong in the deciding doubles, winning 4-1.
In 2015, Butler returned to the BDO, winning the Camellia Classic and USA Dart Classic to claim the BDO America Rankings. He qualified for the Grand Slam of Darts, defeating Scott Waites and Glen Durrant on his way to securing one of the two available places. His biggest achievement of the year came at the World Masters, where he defeated Scott Mitchell, Scott Waites and Martin Adams to reach the final, before losing 7-3 to Glen Durrant. At the Grand Slam of Darts in November 2015, he was drawn alongside Gary Anderson, Raymond van Barneveld and Andy Boulton. He lost 5-0 to Anderson, beat Boulton 5-4, and lost 5-3 to Van Barneveld, failing to reach the knockout stages.
In January 2016, Butler competed at the BDO World Championship for the first time since 1997, a gap of 19 years. He came through the preliminary round 3-2 against James Hurrell and then beat Ryan De Vreede 3-2 to reach the last 32, where he lost 4-0 to top seed and eventual champion Glen Durrant. Towards the end of his career, Butler competed in the World Seniors Championship twice. In 2022, he reached the quarter-finals with victories over Alan Warriner-Little and Keith Deller before losing 3-1 to Martin Adams. A year later, he lost 3-2 to Darren Johnson in the opening round. The now 69-year-old American still regularly competes at various tournaments in his home country.
Larry Butler's World Championship record: BDO 1992 first round lost to Dennis Priestley (1-3); BDO 2016 second round lost to Glen Durrant (0-4); PDC 1994 group stage lost to Tom Kirby (1-3), beat John Lowe (3-2); PDC 1995 group stage beat Keith Deller (3-2), lost to Kevin Spiolek (0-3); PDC 1996 quarter-finals lost to Jamie Harvey (0-4); PDC 1997 group stage lost to Graeme Stoddart (1-3) and Alan Warriner (1-3); WSDT 2022 quarter-finals lost to Martin Adams (1-3); WSDT 2023 first round lost to Darren Johnson (2-3).
More than 30 years after his historic victory, Butler's name remains unique: no other American has yet won a PDC major in Europe. His ability to defeat players such as Scott Mitchell, Scott Waites and Martin Adams later in his career underlined his quality and determination, proving he was not simply a player who benefited from one remarkable week in Blackpool, but someone who performed at a high level over many years.